for Medical Liability Reform and Worker Pension Protection
Madison Central High School
August 7, 2002
10:50 A.M. CDT
Thanks for a warm welcome. Thanks for having me. It's true, Congressman, I did
bring Laura her coffee this morning. (Laughter.) The only thing that was different
from the past is, I brought it to her in Crawford, Texas. (Laughter.) I have
moved my office to Crawford. And I'm so honored my first stop after having moved
my office to Crawford is in the great state of Mississippi. (Applause.)
I want to thank you all for coming. I want to talk about three important goals
for our country. One, win the war on terror. (Applause.) Two, to protect the
homeland. (Applause.) And, three, to make it clear we will not rest until we
have economic security for everybody who lives in America. (Applause.)
That's a goal shared by the Missippeans for Economic Progress, and I want to
thank them for hosting me today. I appreciate you all coming. (Applause.) I
also want to thank the Congressman for introducing me. I also appreciate so
very much two fine -- I mean fine -- United States Senators from the great state
of Mississippi who are here, and that's, of course, Thad Cochran and the man
I call Leader, Trent Lott. (Applause.)
I want to thank very much Ronnie Shows for being here. Congressman, thank you
for coming; I'm honored you're here, I appreciate it. (Applause.) And I want
to thank Roger Wicker, another member of the Mississippi congressional delegation,
for coming. (Applause.) We've got congressmen everywhere. (Laughter.)
But there's one special former congressman with us. It's a man -- when I'm in
Washington, I go to church right across the street from the White House and
this fellow always saves me a pew -- he's been a great friend of my family's,
he's a great friend of Mississippi, he is the namesake of the Montgomery Institute
in Meridian, Mississippi, and that's Sonny Montgomery. (Applause.) It looks
like they still remember you, Sonny -- (laughter) -- and love you, just like
I want to thank members of the State House for coming. The Governor kindly came
out to greet me today, and I'm thankful for the Governor for being there. I
want to thank the Lieutenant Governor, Governor Tuck, for coming today. I want
to appreciate the State Senator, Travis Little, and all the other members of
the State House who are here. It makes me feel welcome for you to come and to
greet me. I thank you from the bottom of my heart.
I also want to thank the Mayors who are here. Mayor Mary Hawkins-Butler of Madison
is here. I want to thank you, Madam Mayor, for coming. (Applause.) And Mayor
Gene McGee, the Mayor of Ridgeland, Mississippi is here. (Applause.) David Allen
is the Vice Chairman of the Mississippians for Economic Progress, who gathered
you all up. And I want to thank you, David and yr group, for supporting this
event. I want to thank Jay Reeves, who is the Principal of the Madison Central
High School, for having us. (Applause.) I want to thank the Madison High Band.
Listen, you all were great when you serenaded us coming in. (Laughter.) I tried
to pop out of the limousine -- (laughter) to say thanks, but it was moving a
little too fast. (Laughter.) But I do want to thank you all. The principal was
telling me you're an award-winning band and I so much appreciate the fact that
you played. Unfortunately, most band members are in the overflow room, so if
you're listening, thanks.
I also want to thank Mike Kent, who is the Madison County Superintendent of
Education. I want to thank the folks who I just met with, Mississippi citizens
from all walks of life who expressed their concerns to me on a variety of issues.
And I'll be discussing some of those issues. I met with some of the kindest,
most decent doctors you can possibly imagine who are with us today, people who
love their communities, love their profession, are deeply concerned about the
future of medicine in this state.
I met WorldCom employees who no longer have work, who are disillusioned, like
me and others, about the corporate fraud which is taking place in our country.
I met with small business owners who long to have an environment that will allow
them to flourish. So I want to thank them for coming. I'm going to talk more
about some of the issues around these participants. But you've got some fine
folks in this state, and they took time to visit and share their frustrations
with me. I want to thank them all for coming today, very much.
I also want to welcome Star Wallin here. One of the things I love to do as I
travel the country is to meet soldiers in the armies of compassion, people who
have heard the call to love a neighbor just like they'd like to be loved themselves;
people who don't wait for a President to say, you will go love somebody, or
Congress to pass a law; people who understand that part of being an American
is to serve your community by helping people in need.
Star is here. She's the founder of what's called Project CARE -- Compassion
in Action creates a Ripple Effect for positive change. The unusual thing about
Star is she's 18 years old. She has -- that's not unusual, there's a lot of
18 year olds. (Laughter.) What is unusual is, is that she is signing-up people
who went to her school to help people in need. As a result of her vision and
her work and her compassion, 300 elementary school students were mentored by
upperclassmen. The 300 benefited, as did the mentors. As a result of her vision,
she has rallied people to feed the needy, to provide furniture for those who
want. She has helped restore playgrounds on public schools. As a result of her
vision, her community is better. She has set a fabulous example. Star, thank
you for being here and thank you for what you do. (Applause.)
And I want to thank your family for being here as well. They did a pretty darn
good job of raising you.
My most important job as the President of this country is to protect the homeland.
My most important job is to rally our governments to do everything humanly possible
to prevent the enemy former taking innocent life again. That job goes on because
the enemy still exists, an enemy that hates freedom and therefore hates America;
people who can't stand the thought that we worship freely in this country, and
therefore hate us; cold-blooded killers who don't value life the way we value
And so they're still a threat to the homeland, there is still a threat that
they might attack us again. And, therefore, you need to know that your government
is doing everything humanly possible. A lot of fine folks are working overtime
doing everything humanly possible to run down every hint, every lead, every
piece of evidence to protect the homeland.
I got to Washington, and after being there for a while I took a look at the
homeland security apparatus there in the nation's capital. There are over 100
different agencies involved with homeland security. As I like to say, they're
scattered everywhere. And if they're scattered everywhere, it makes it hard
to hold people accountable. And we need accountability all throughout government
-- nothing more important, though, than to have accountability when it comes
to protecting the homeland.
I felt like having taken a look at the situation that in order to set the number
one priority of all those agencies is a protection of homeland, they needed
to be under one agency, one Cabinet officer. And so I proposed to the country,
to the Congress, that we have a Department of Homeland Security that will be
charged with enforcing our borders. Listen, we need to know who's coming in
the country, what they're bringing in the country, why they're coming into the
country and if they're leaving when they're supposed to be leaving the country.
We need to work with our courageous first responders, the firefighters and the
police and the EMS teams all across our country to prepare -- prepare as best
as we possibly can for emergency. We need to be prepared other respond to a
terrorism attack using weapons of mass destruction. We need to better coordinate
intelligence -- we get intelligence gathered here and there and we need somebody
to analyze this, to address the vulnerabilities, assess the vulnerabilities
so that we can address them, to make the homeland more secure. That's a major
task of the Office of Homeland Security.
This isn't a Republican issue, folks. This isn't a Democrat issue. This is an
American issue. This is what we need to do. We need to leave a legacy behind.
(Applause.) And when we create the department, we've got to do it right. See,
we're trying to leave a legacy not only for future Presidents, but future Congress
so they can deal with the true threats of the 21st century. We're in a different
And you need to know that I'm not interested in having to try to run a clumsy,
slow-moving bureaucracy, that when we fashion a new department, we must be able
to react. We've got to be able to put the right people in the right job at the
right time, without a thick book of rules that have little to do with protecting
the American people.
The number one priority of this agency must be the protection of the people,
as opposed to representing narrow political interests. (Applause.) I want to
thank the members of the House of Representatives who heard that message, who
put their political turf aside and focused on the American people. Now the Senate
must hear the message. These two Senators have heard the message, and I want
to thank them for their leadership -- I want to thank them for their leadership.
The leadership of the Senate must focus on what's best for America, not what's
best on narrow interests, and get a bill to my desk that will enable me to say
to the American people, we're doing everything we can to protect the homeland.
(Applause.) The best way to protect the homeland in the long run is to hunt
the killers down, one by one, and bring them to justice, which is what we're
going to do. (Applause.)
This is a different kind of war. The leaders hide in caves and send youngsters
to their death. But there's no cave deep enough, no cave dark enough for an
America, a resolved America, that loves our freedom. And so no matter how long
it takes, no matter what the cost might be, for the sake of our freedom, and
for the sake of our children, and our children's children, we're going to hunt
them down. These are nothing but international criminals, and they're going
to be treated as international criminals. (Applause.)
And we're making good progress, we really are. It's hard to tell it sometimes,
because as we make progress, sometimes it doesn't get on your cable channel.
(Laughter.) But you need to know we're making progress. We've hauled in, or
captured -- and I say "we," we've got a mighty coalition of countries
from around the world that love freedom, just like we love freedom, and they
understand the true threats that we face. And we've captured over 2,000 of them
in a pretty quick period of time. Another group of them, just about the same
number, weren't quite as lucky. (Applause.)
But we've got a lot of work to do. I want the youngsters here, the high school
students here to know that we seek -- we don't seek revenge, we seek justice.
And when we go into a country, we do so not to conquer, but to liberate. There
are young girls going to school in Afghanistan for the first time, thanks to
the mighty government -- mighty United States military and our friends and allies.
And that's important for you to remember. (Applause.)
We face threats because we love freedom. Al Qaeda represents threats, and we're
dealing with them. There are countries which harbor and develop weapons of mass
destruction, countries run by people who poison their own people, countries
whose leadership has got a terrible record when it comes to valuing life, particularly
inside their own country.
And these are real threats, and we owe it to our children to deal with these
threats. I promise you that I am -- will be patient and deliberate, that we
will continue to consult with Congress, and of course we'll consult with our
friends and allies. We will discuss these threats in real terms. And I will
explore all options and all tools at my disposal. Diplomacy, international pressure,
perhaps the military. But it's important for my fellow citizens to know that
as we see threats evolving we will deal with them. We must deal with them. History
has called us into action. We love freedom and we'll deal with the threats that
could eventually hurt our freedoms. (Applause.)
I've asked for the biggest increase in defense spending since Ronald Reagan
was the President for two reasons. One, any time we commit our troops into harm's
way, they deserve the best pay, the best training, the best equipment possible.
And, two, the defense budget sends a signal to our friends, allies, and to the
enemy, that we're in this for the long haul; that we love our freedom so much
that we're in it for the long pull.
I appreciate the fact that the House of Representatives has passed the defense
appropriations bill and the senate has passed a defense appropriations bill.
But taking care of our military must be the first order of business when Congress
returns back to Washington. We owe the military every tool they need and every
dollar it takes to win this war. And, therefore, I call upon the leadership
of the Congress to resolve quickly, quickly resolve the differences between
the House appropriations bill for defense and the Senate appropriations bill
for defense and get that bill to my desk first thing when they get back so I
can sign it. (Applause.)
I'm going to work to build the economics, the foundations for economic security
for our people. And I believe the foundation is strong. Listen, our economy
is growing. It's getting better. Inflation is low. The great news -- and I'm
not surprised at this -- is that worker productivity is increasing dramatically.
I'm not surprised because I know the American people. I know that the true strength
of the country is our people. But listen, so long as anybody is looking for
work and can't find work, I think we've got a problem. When somebody is out
there and says, I want to work and can't find a job, we need to do something
about it. Look, the role of government is not t create wealth, but an environment
in which the economy can grow.
Everybody here knows this, we're not going to tax our way to prosperity, we
won't regulate our way to prosperity, we certainly won't litigate our way to
prosperity. (Applause.) What we need to do is -- what we need to do is to always
ask the question, how do we increase job growth and honest enterprise -- and
When I took office, our economy was beginning a recession. That's what the facts
have shown. Then our economy was hit by terrorists. Then our economy was hit
by corporate scandals. But I'm certain of this, we won't let fear undermine
our economy, and we're not going to let fraud undermine it either. (Applause.)
I appreciate the work of both Republicans and Democrats to pass the biggest
corporate reforms since Franklin Roosevelt was the President. And I had the
honor of signing that, and working with members of both parties to get this
bill done. We're going to make sure the books are honest, the numbers are real,
the auditors are audited, and the criminals are punished. (Applause.)
And the task force I put together is beginning to make progress. They're investigating,
arresting, and will soon be prosecuting those who have betrayed the trust of
employee and shareholder alike. For corporate leaders found guilty of fraud
and theft, there will be no more easy money, just hard time. (Applause.)
And here in Mississippi, you know what I'm talking about. You know what it means
to be let down by shady corporate practices. Two of the good folks with whom
I met earlier today had been let down by shady corporate practices. They lost
their jobs and a good portion of their retirement funds because there was corporate
malfeasance. They were cooking the books, they weren't open and honest. People
who dedicate their lives to building the company who hired them deserve better,
not only here in Mississippi, but all over the country. People who invested
in a local company because of state pride deserve better. By raising the standards
of conduct in corporate America, we're going to protect the jobs. By holding
people accountable, we'll protect jobs -- and as importantly, retirement security
all across the country.
And speaking about that, we've got to do more to protect worker pensions. Right
now, too many workers are locked into plans that force them to hold a large
portion of their accounts in their company stock. There are a lot of plans that
won't let people diversify. And that's not right. I believe workers ought to
be able to diversify after three years in their company's plan. I think we ought
to trust workers with their own money. (Applause.)
Right now, workers get an update every year. They ought to get updates every
three months on their plan. (Applause.) They should be able to get sound investment
advice. After all, it's their money. I proposed these reforms months ago. The
House acted. The Senate hasn't. (Laughter.) The Senate leadership, those who
are running the Senate now ought to bring these worker reforms forward. They
ought to get this pension reform bill up and to my desk as soon as they get
back from their vacations. (Applause.)
And I'm not talking about the Senate leaders here on the front row, either.
(Laughter.) Here in Mississippi you're learning a hard lesson. That one of the
biggest obstacles to growth is the lawsuit industry. (Applause.)
That's one industry we don't want to see grow. Junk and frivolous lawsuits can
ruin an honest business. Listen, small business is the backbone of our society.
Most new jobs are created by small business. And when you have junk and frivolous
lawsuits that could completely wipe out a small business hanging over the heads
of small business people, it doesn't help. It hurts economic vitality and economic
growth, and you've got to understand that. (Applause.)
And in this state, the lawsuit industry is devastating the practice of medicine.
(Applause.) And people around the country understand this is happening here.
They're getting the message that the fastest growing industry is the lawsuit
industry. Too many frivolous lawsuits in this state are beginning filed against
doctors. That's a fact. And too many jury awards are out of control. (Applause.)
You've got too many of your doctors that are being forced to settle cases for
large amounts of money even when they haven't committed an error. And that's
not right, because you know who it hurts? It hurts the people, it hurts the
people of Mississippi. (Applause.) It causes medicine, the cost of medicine
to go up, and that means people have to pay more money out of their pocket --
all people. You may not think so, but it's a hidden cost of your health care
You know what else it does? Because premiums go up, or liabilities are threatening
-- lawsuits are threatening doctors -- I mean, some of the docs can't get insurance
coverage, which means they no longer want to provide care. And that hurts people,
too. Not only does excessive lawsuits cause your bill to go up, it makes it
awfully hard for people in some parts of your state to even get medical care.
And that's a crime, and that's a shame. (Applause.)
And that's a problem here in Mississippi, and in other states, too. I just met
with some Mississippi doctors. These are people that love their communities,
and care deeply for their patients. But they are practicing their medicine in
the face of hostile legal environments. These are good docs who can't get liability
insurance or given up their specialties or leaving their practices to go somewhere
else. It's estimated by some that this great state could lose 10 percent of
your physicians, unless you do something about it.
I want to tell you about Dr. Kooyer. He's sitting right out there. He and his
wife went to Rolling Fork, Mississippi, in the heart of the Delta. They did
because, as he said, he felt a Christian calling to care for children, children
who need help. That's what he heard. Not only did he have skills, he's got a
heart. But because of frivolous lawsuits, because every time he turns the corner
somebody might sue him, and because of his rising liability insurance premiums,
he's leaving your state. He doesn't want to leave your state, he loves Mississippi,
he loves helping those who need help. He loves being a pediatrician, and so
does his wife, but he's had it.
And so he's leaving, which means there will be no pediatrician in that county
in Mississippi. And that's a shame. Lawsuits are driving them out of your state.
It's hurting people. It's not hurting big institutions, it's hurting the people.
Dr. Frothingham, you talk about a man with a heart. You think Kooyer has a heart?
Wait until you hear Frothingham. (Laughter.) He's a great Mississippian; grew
up here; thought he might try to live in South Carolina, realized what he was
missing, came back to Mississippi. (Laughter.) He's a neurosurgeon. He talked
with deep compassion about a man who suffered a trauma, a fellow he was with
-- Johnny was with us today. He's a guy who understands that practicing medicine
is more than just technology. It's concern and care.
They're running him out of business. There's too many frivolous lawsuits. And
that hurts the state and it hurts the country. It hurts people. Jill Mahaffey,
says she got lucky. She and her husband are here, they live in the Delta, too.
She got lucky. She heard she's pregnant. She's getting there, getting ready.
She goes to the doctor, he says, I've got to leave -- OB/GYN getting ready to
leave because of lawsuits, because of the threats.
Because even if you're a doctor who practices good medicine, you're going to
get sued in this state and in other states. Believe this or not, fortunately,
she was getting toxic and the doc induced labor before he quit his practice.
She says she was lucky. And she was.
But these human stories, these stories of people going without or could go without,
they've got to end in this country. And it's not just in Mississippi. There
are other states being affected by the lawsuit industry. And we need to do something
about it. This state needs to do something about it and so does Washington,
D.C. need to do something about these frivolous lawsuits. (Applause.)
Well, some say that's not a federal issue. Here you are in Mississippi, you're
talking about Mississippi's problem, leave it in Mississippi -- that's a federal
issue, I'll tell you why. If you agree with me that these junk lawsuits run
up the cost of medicine, then it becomes a federal issue when you realize all
the dollars we spend on Medicare. It's a federal issue when you think about
all the money we spend on Medicaid to help people. It's a federal issue when
you think about all the veterans hospitals around the country.
No, it's a federal issue and it's time for the Congress to pass a minimum federal
standard which says this: one, if you're hurt, you ought to have your day in
court and you ought to be able to recover full economic damages -- no problem
about that, everybody agrees with that. If you get hurt, you ought to be able
to go to your court, the courthouse and be treated; you ought to get fair compensation
for your economic damages.
But we cannot have unlimited, non-economic damages and punitive damages drive
health care away from the people. (Applause.) So I strongly support, and I urge
Congress to have reasonable federal limits on non-economic damages -- $250,000
is reasonable. I think we ought to have a cap on punitive damages. I think we
ought to have joint and several* liability reform. And I know we ought to allow
doctors and folks who work in hospitals to be able to evaluate practice, to
be able to analyze best practices on behalf of the patients without fear of
a frivolous or junk lawsuit. (Applause.)
It's time for Congress to act. It's time. This liability system of ours should
serve patients, not trial lawyers. (Applause.) There's more we can do, and I
look forward to working with Congress to make sure economic security is solid
in America. You know, I believe that when you let a man or a woman keep more
of his or her own money, it means he or she is going to demand a good or a service.
And when they demand a good or a service, somebody is going to produce the good
and service. And when somebody produces a good and service, somebody is likely
to expand the job base. That's the school of economic thought I come from. (Applause.)
And that's why I worked closely with then-Leader Lott and Speaker Hastert, and
people from both parties, to pass a significant tax reduction on behalf of the
American people. (Applause.) This tax reduction was well-timed. When you look
at the fact that our economy was now -- as we found out -- in recession when
I took office. It's well-timed. When people have more of their own money, it's
how you fight a recession. And that was important.
But interestingly enough, as a result of a quirk in the law of the Senate, these
tax reforms, these tax reductions -- not only income tax reductions, but significantly
reducing the marriage penalty, and repealing the death tax -- all those go away,
all those reductions after 10 years. For the sake of economic vitality, for
the sake of allowing people to plan, for the sake of small businesses and farmers
and ranchers all across the country, we need to make the tax reductions permanent.
We need to make sure that construction projects go forward. And after September
the 11th, about $8 billion worth of construction projects were delayed or killed
because people couldn't get lending, couldn't get commercial property financing
for the lack of terrorism insurance. The Congress needs to act on this issue.
For the sake of the hard hats here in America, for the good, hard-working people
in Mississippi people that are building bridges and commercial projects, for
the people's sake -- blue collar workers all across America -- we need to get
a terrorism insurance bill that will provide some surety so that these commercial
projects can go forward, so that our construction workers will be back to work.
It's time for the House and the Senate to reconcile its differences and as you
do so, make sure that you keep the workers in mind, and not the lawyers. (Applause.)
So I wanted to come to Mississippi to talk to you about our nation's priorities.
And I want to thank you for giving me a chance to come. I want to tell you how
I feel about the country and its future. You're looking at an optimist. There
is no problem we can't solve in this country. I believe out of the evil done
to America is going to come some incredible good. (Applause.)
I say that with certainty because the strength of the country is the American
people. The American people have got great hearts, great resolve, great compassion,
and great determination. This country is going to lead the world to peace. No,
I know all the war rhetoric, but it's all aimed at achieving peace. That's my
I want there to be peace for generations of Americans. I want there to peace
for generations of Israelis and Palestinians, peace in South Asia. And by being
strong and determined, by speaking clearly about good and evil, by being patient
and resolved, I believe that we can help lead the world to peace.
And here at home, and here at home, we can lead -- all of us can lead our country
to a more compassionate future. There are pockets of despair in America. There
are pockets of addiction and hopelessness. So long as one of us suffers, all
of us suffers, as far as I'm concerned. And, yet, I fully understand the limitations
of government. We can hand out money in Washington, D.C., but we can't put hope
in people's hearts, or a sense of purpose in people's lives.
I wish I knew the law that would say, we will all love each other. Lott would
sponsor it, I'd sign it. (Laughter and applause.) There is no government law
-- there's a universal law, there's a higher law. And that's really the strength
of America. People have heard that call. People say, what can I do to help after
September the 11th. And I've said, love your neighbor. If you want to help,
mentor a child. If you want to help, go see a shut-in and tell them you love
them. If you want to help, feed the hungry, build a house with Habitat, run
a Boy Scout troop or a Girl Scout troop. If you want to help, just tell somebody,
I care for you, I hope you -- I hope if you've got a problem, you come and call
on me. You see, America can be saved one heart, one soul, one conscience at
a time. (Applause.)
One person can't do everything, I know that. The task seems large, but one person
can do something. I'm asking you to be that one person doing something to help
make your community and Mississippi and our nation a place of hope, a place
of decency, a place of compassion for every citizen who is fortunate enough
to be an American.
No, the enemy hit us, they hit us, but they didn't know who they were hitting.
Oh, they probably thought we'd file a lawsuit or two. (Laughter and applause.)
But they hit a nation that loves freedom, and we'll defend our freedoms. They
also found out about our heart, that out of the evil done to America will come
incredible good, because we're the greatest nation on the face of the earth.